Professor Eric K. K. Abavare warns against weakening constitutional accountability, calls for stronger safeguards for anti-corruption institutions and demands reforms to customary land administration.
A lecturer at the Kwame Nkrumah University of Science and Technology (KNUST), who also serves as President of the university’s chapter of the University Teachers Association of Ghana (UTAG), Professor Eric K. K. Abavare, has called for significant revisions to five proposals contained in the 2025 Constitutional Review Committee (CRC) Report, describing them as potential threats to effective governance and democratic accountability.
In the concluding article of his nine-part commentary on the report, Professor Abavare singled out the proposed extension of Ghana’s presidential term from four to five years as the most concerning recommendation, insisting that the existing four-year mandate should be maintained.
He argued that extending the presidential term could weaken electoral accountability by allowing governments to remain in office for longer periods before voters have the opportunity to assess their performance and determine whether they deserve another mandate.
The other four areas he identified for reconsideration are the proposed Anti-Corruption and Ethics Commission (AEC), the election of Metropolitan, Municipal and District Chief Executives (MMDCEs) on a non-partisan basis, the administration of stool and skin lands, and the constitutional responsibilities of the Vice-President.
Despite his reservations, Professor Abavare described the CRC Report as one of Ghana’s most significant attempts at constitutional reform in a generation, acknowledging its proposals to address executive dominance, weak local governance and accountability deficiencies.
He, however, cautioned against accepting the recommendations without adequate scrutiny, arguing that some provisions could create new institutional weaknesses if adopted without appropriate safeguards.
Professor Abavare has rejected the proposal to extend Ghana’s presidential term from four to five years, describing it as the most dangerous recommendation in the CRC Report.
He maintained that the existing four-year presidential mandate under the 1992 Constitution remains a critical accountability mechanism that allows citizens to periodically evaluate the performance of elected governments.
According to him, retaining the two-term presidential limit while extending each term to five years would increase the maximum period a president could remain in office from eight to ten years.
He argued that this would represent a 25 per cent increase in the period citizens could be governed by an administration before having the opportunity to elect a new government.
He also questioned the argument that a longer presidential term would necessarily improve governance and development outcomes, warning that it could encourage complacency, delay policy reforms and allow administrative failures to persist for longer periods.
“If the Committee’s real concern is that four years is not enough to deliver, the answer is not a longer calendar,” he argued.
As an alternative, he advocated stronger civil service continuity, professional transitions between successive governments, a binding National Development Plan and disciplined fiscal management.
He consequently urged Ghanaians to oppose the proposed extension and retain the four-year presidential term.
On the proposed establishment of an Anti-Corruption and Ethics Commission, Professor Abavare warned that the institution could become ineffective if its financial and operational independence were not adequately protected.
Although he supported the creation of a dedicated anti-corruption institution, he argued that the commission must be insulated from political interference to enable it to investigate and address corruption without undue executive influence.
He cautioned that a politically captured commission could undermine public confidence and become an instrument for selective enforcement.
“A politically captured Anti-Corruption and Ethics Commission would be worse than no AEC at all because it would be corruption with an official seal on the letterhead,” he stated.
To safeguard its independence, he proposed that the commission receive funding through a fixed statutory percentage of national revenue, with protection against executive interference through the annual Appropriation Bill.
He further recommended that the commissioner’s removal protections be comparable to those enjoyed by justices of the Superior Courts.
Additionally, he called for the commission’s board to be constituted through the proposed reformed Council of State appointment process to minimise political control.
He maintained that without these safeguards, the proposed commission could become another public institution vulnerable to partisan influence rather than an effective accountability mechanism.
Professor Abavare has also questioned whether the proposed non-partisan election of MMDCEs would achieve its intended objective without strict enforcement measures.
While supporting efforts to strengthen local democracy through the election of local government executives, he argued that describing the contests as non-partisan would not automatically prevent political parties from influencing the process.
He warned that political parties could sponsor candidates who formally contest as independents while receiving financial, organisational and logistical support from party structures.
To prevent this, he called for legislation expressly prohibiting political party endorsements, campaign financing, party symbols and emblems, as well as the involvement of party campaign personnel in MMDCE elections.
He also proposed strict sanctions, including the disqualification of candidates who violate the restrictions.
According to him, the effectiveness of the proposed reform will depend on the strength of its enforcement provisions rather than simply the constitutional designation of the elections as non-partisan.
Another concern raised by the KNUST UTAG president is what he considers the CRC’s failure to adequately address the administration of stool and skin lands.
He argued that the proposed reforms concerning public lands would remain incomplete if customary land administration were excluded from the broader constitutional reform agenda.
Professor Abavare noted that stool and skin lands represent a significant category of land ownership in Ghana and have been associated with prolonged disputes, litigation and allegations of unfair dispossession.
He therefore called for a parallel reform framework to introduce transparency and accountability into the administration of customary lands.
His proposals include establishing a mandatory public register of land allocations to improve access to information about land transactions and ownership.
He also advocated a transparent revenue-sharing arrangement involving traditional authorities, local communities and District Assemblies.
He believes these measures would reduce land disputes, strengthen public confidence and ensure that communities benefit more equitably from customary land resources.
Professor Abavare has further criticised the CRC’s decision not to assign specific constitutional responsibilities to the Vice-President.
He argued that leaving the officeholder’s functions largely to the discretion of the sitting President creates uncertainty and exposes the country’s executive governance structure to avoidable institutional weaknesses.
He acknowledged the committee’s concern that formally dividing executive responsibilities between the President and Vice-President could trigger jurisdictional conflicts but maintained that this was not a sufficient reason to leave the office without a clearly defined constitutional mandate.
He maintained that Ghana’s experience with presidential succession underscores the need for a more structured role for the Vice-President.
As a possible solution, he proposed making the Vice-President the constitutional chairperson of a defined inter-ministerial body, such as a reformed National Development Planning Commission.
According to him, this would give the officeholder a substantive responsibility, establish clearer accountability and ensure continuity in national development planning.
Beyond the five contentious recommendations, Professor Abavare has cautioned against potential risks associated with the CRC’s proposed three-tier constitutional amendment framework.
The proposal seeks to introduce a semi-entrenched category of constitutional provisions that could be amended through a 75 per cent parliamentary majority without a national referendum.
The fully entrenched category would be reserved for provisions considered fundamental to the identity and democratic character of the Constitution, including constitutional supremacy, presidential term limits, core media freedoms and the multi-party system.
Professor Abavare acknowledged the rationale behind the proposal, noting that Ghana’s existing constitutional amendment requirements can make certain reforms difficult to implement.
However, he warned that the proposed semi-entrenched category could allow a government with the required parliamentary majority to alter significant constitutional provisions without directly seeking the approval of the electorate.
He therefore outlined four conditions that should guide the adoption of the framework.
First, the list of fully entrenched provisions must be expressly stated in the amended Constitution and protected by a referendum requirement rather than left to future legislation.
Second, all provisions relating to the President’s term, tenure and eligibility must remain fully entrenched.
Third, the proposed cap of 15 justices on the Supreme Court must also receive full constitutional protection to prevent future governments from changing the court’s composition through parliamentary majorities.
Fourth, any proposed popular initiative amendment mechanism should require a five per cent signature threshold across a majority of Ghana’s 16 regions, rather than relying solely on a national signature total.
He argued that these safeguards would prevent powerful interest groups concentrated in Accra from initiating constitutional changes without adequate participation from other parts of the country.
Despite his concerns, Professor Abavare maintained that the majority of the CRC’s recommendations deserve public support.
He expressed support for proposed reforms relating to Parliament, the Judiciary, land and natural resources, local government, human rights and independent constitutional bodies, arguing that they generally satisfy his standards of accountability, public interest and institutional safeguards.
He also endorsed several recommendations under the Presidency chapter, including a cap on Cabinet size, a prohibition on Members of Parliament serving as ministers, the taxation of presidential salaries and reforms to the presidential appointments process.
However, he insisted that the proposed Supreme Court membership cap must be fully entrenched to protect judicial independence.
His overall position is that Ghanaians should neither accept nor reject the CRC Report in its entirety.
Instead, he wants Parliament to retain the reforms that strengthen democratic governance while returning contentious proposals for further consideration and redrafting.
Professor Abavare has called on Ghanaians to take an active interest in the constitutional reform process, warning that implementing the CRC recommendations could take at least two electoral cycles.
He anticipated that the process would involve the preparation of a government White Paper, the drafting of amendment Bills, parliamentary debates and national referendums for provisions requiring popular approval.
He outlined three key responsibilities for citizens.
First, he urged Ghanaians to read the CRC Report, or at least its executive summary, and form independent opinions rather than relying solely on political parties or media commentators.
Second, he called on citizens to demand clear public positions from Members of Parliament, ministerial nominees and presidential aspirants ahead of the 2028 general elections on the five contentious proposals he had identified.
Third, he urged the public to protect the referendum requirements for fully entrenched constitutional provisions.
He warned against any attempt during the drafting process to transfer fundamental safeguards, including the two-term presidential limit, the proposed Supreme Court size cap, the abolition of the death penalty and the vesting of public lands in the state, into the semi-entrenched category.
Reflecting on the importance of the constitutional reform exercise, Professor Abavare recalled that Ghana’s 1992 Constitution was adopted under exceptional circumstances following decades of unconstitutional rule.
He noted that the Constitution received 92 per cent approval in the referendum that preceded the country’s return to constitutional democratic governance.
He said any successor constitutional framework must be approached with similar seriousness, broad public participation and national commitment.
The university professor also expressed appreciation to readers who followed his nine-part commentary, particularly those who shared the articles, offered corrections, raised questions and challenged his arguments.
He explained that the objective of the series was to make the constitutional reform debate accessible to ordinary Ghanaians rather than leave the interpretation of the proposed changes exclusively to legal professionals and political elites.
Concluding his assessment, he said the CRC had completed its responsibility, but the task of ensuring that the proposed reforms serve the national interest now rests with citizens.
“The CRC has done its part of the work. It is now our turn,” he stated.
Professor Eric K. K. Abavare is the President of the KNUST chapter of UTAG and an independent commentator on constitutional and public-policy reform. The views expressed are personal.
By 1960news.com
